Flying in the Face of Criminalization

Flying in the Face of Criminalization

4.11 - 1251 ratings - Source

Two parallel investigations take place after every aviation accident: one technical, one judicial. The former must be conducted with the sole intention of making safety recommendations to prevent the recurrence of similar accidents. The judicial investigation, however, has the intention of identifying those parties that have been at fault and to apportion blameworthiness for criminal and civil liability. Consequently, this results in a predicament for those parties that have been identified as having played a role in the accident, a dilemma between not supplying information aimed at enhancing safety and preventing future accidents and, on the other hand, supplying such information which may possibly be used against them in subsequent criminal prosecution. The situation is compounded by inconsistent approaches between different legal systems; aviation professionals may find themselves faced with criminal charges in one country but not in another, and they may also be unsure as to whether statements given during the technical investigation could be used against them in a court of law. Aviation safety is, to a large extent, built upon the trust placed by pilots, ATCOs and other aviation professionals in the process of accident investigation. This book examines the growing trend to criminalize these same people following an accident investigation and considers the implications this has for aviation safety.Comission da#39;enquAote sur la#39;accident survenu le 26 juin 1988 a Mulhouse- Habsheim (68) a la#39;Airbus A 320, immatriculAc F-GFKC. Report f-kc880626. Available at: http://www.bea. aero/docspa/1988/fkc880626/pdf/fkc880626.pdf | accessed: 6 March 2005]. BEA ... le 20janvier 1992 prAus du Mont SainteOdile ( Bas Rhin) a la#39;Airbus A320 immatriculAc F-GGED exploitAc par la compagnie Air Inter. ... a€œRe-inventing (with wheels, wings and sails) a new look at transport accident investigator training.

Title:Flying in the Face of Criminalization
Author:Captain Andreas Mateou, Dr Sofia Michaelides-Mateou
Publisher:Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. - 2012-10-01


You Must CONTINUE and create a free account to access unlimited downloads & streaming